★FINAL DROP
DEEP FRIED SANDWICH COOKIE
$14.99
In This Drop · Name Withheld
BUY IT
BLIND.
One jar in this drop doesn’t get a name. It’s a 90’s freezer-aisle legend, back in a jar — we’re just not telling you which one until it’s in your hands. Take the swing. It’s cheaper than the rest for the trouble.
TAKE THE MYSTERY JARAllergens, so nobody gets surprised: contains milk, cashew, wheat and soy. Made in a facility that also processes peanuts.
THE DROP
Every flavor in this drop, all in one place.
NUTTYFINGER ICE CREAM BAR
$14.99
IMAGINARY PIE
$14.99
NEW FORMULA
MATILDA CAKE
$14.99
90'S SCHWAG
$14.99
MYSTERY
MYSTERY FLAVOR
$14.99$12.75
S'MORES CANDY BAR
$14.99
SOLD OUT
★TOP
RATED
RATED
COOKIE BUTTER BAR
$14.99
SOLD OUT
4000+ Adults Got To
Feel Like Kids Again
This is EXACTLY like going to the fair and getting the deep fried cookies.
Perfect blend of flavors and consistency, with just a touch of magic.
It was very much giving death by chocolate cake in a jar! Obsessed!
Ommmmmg I love this one! Only regret is only ordering one jar!
90's Schwag is absolutely amazing and perfect for toast!
CH 01
More Flavors Coming Soon
Sold-out flavors on their way back. Get notified the second they restock.
Cowabunga Pies
Sold Out Notify Me
90's Crisps
Sold Out Notify Me
PB Max'd
Sold Out Notify Me
Homey's D'ohnut
Sold Out Notify MeFREQUENTLY ASKED
Do my Nostalgic Desserts need to be refrigerated?
Unless otherwise noted on the label or cap, 95% of our flavors are shelf-stable and do NOT need to be refrigerated!
Are they safe for my allergies?
Every flavor's full ingredients and allergens are listed right on its product page under “What's Inside.” Check there before ordering — and reach out if you're ever unsure.
Why are some Nostalgic Desserts layered?
This is a very good question. To truly capture a flavor — let's say Ice Cream Truck Strawberry Shortcake — you can't just have a base nut butter with a bunch of different flavorings mixed in, then throw toppings on the base and expect it to taste authentic. You won't get the true taste of the flavor you're trying to replicate. Sure, it's easier to do it that way, but creating perfection isn't easy — which is why we truly mimic the flavor by using the layers.
Do you ship internationally?
Unfortunately we do not at the moment. Sorry about that!
What's the free-shipping threshold?
Orders of $65 or more ship free.
Returns & money-back guarantee?
Every order is backed by our 30-day money-back guarantee. Not happy with it? We'll make it right.
FIRST DIBS ON EVERY DROP.
Drops sell out. Get early access + 10% off your first order.