FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $65 OR MORE

EXCELLENT 4.86/5 CUSTOMER REVIEWS

NEW DROP
NOW LIVE.

SHOP THE DROP

In This Drop · Name Withheld

BUY IT
BLIND.

A hidden mystery flavor

One jar in this drop doesn’t get a name. This one came off a lunch tray. It showed up frozen, you were supposed to let it thaw, and nobody ever did. We’re not telling you which one it is until it’s in your hands. It’s cheaper than the rest for the trouble.

TAKE THE MYSTERY JAR

Allergens, so nobody gets surprised: contains peanuts, milk, wheat and soy.

THE DROP

Every flavor in this drop, all in one place.

The six new Nutty and Nostalgic jars lined up on a 1990s convenience store counter

SOME MEMORIES
YOU CAN TASTE.

Every one of these was discontinued. We put them back on the counter. Six jars.

SHOP THE DROP

4.86/5 CUSTOMER REVIEWS

4000+ Adults Got To
Feel Like Kids Again

90's Crisps
I was worried the crisp part of this wouldn't stay crispy but it's perfect. Really brings you back to the best decade of flavors.
RU D.✓ VERIFIED BUYER
Cowabunga Pies
First time trying this flavor! I can't say I didn't like it! It tastes like a vanilla pudding pie, so good!
KATJA✓ VERIFIED BUYER
PB Max'd
Crunchy layer is amazing, and a great balance of chocolate and peanut butter. Haven't had a flavor from Nutty Nostalgic I didn't love!
KG✓ VERIFIED BUYER
Nutty Grizzlies
Nothing much to say just plainly delicious and creamy
VERONICA S.✓ VERIFIED BUYER
90's Pizza Chip
Normally I don't really like nutty flavors, but I think it really added to the whole thing, especially the Smokey taste of the almonds!
LINDA F.✓ VERIFIED BUYER
Strawberry Cheesecake Snack Bar
This is basically strawberry cheesecake in a jar and tastes exactly like the original
JAMES K.✓ VERIFIED BUYER
CH 01
▶ SEE ALL REVIEWS

More Flavors Coming Soon

Sold-out flavors on their way back. Get notified the second they restock.

See All Flavors

FREQUENTLY ASKED

Do my Nostalgic Desserts need to be refrigerated?

Unless otherwise noted on the label or cap, 95% of our flavors are shelf-stable and do NOT need to be refrigerated!

Are they safe for my allergies?

Every flavor's full ingredients and allergens are listed right on its product page under “What's Inside.” Check there before ordering — and reach out if you're ever unsure.

Why are some Nostalgic Desserts layered?

This is a very good question. To truly capture a flavor — let's say Ice Cream Truck Strawberry Shortcake — you can't just have a base nut butter with a bunch of different flavorings mixed in, then throw toppings on the base and expect it to taste authentic. You won't get the true taste of the flavor you're trying to replicate. Sure, it's easier to do it that way, but creating perfection isn't easy — which is why we truly mimic the flavor by using the layers.

Do you ship internationally?

Unfortunately we do not at the moment. Sorry about that!

What's the free-shipping threshold?

Orders of $65 or more ship free.

Returns & money-back guarantee?

Every order is backed by our 30-day money-back guarantee. Not happy with it? We'll make it right.

FIRST DIBS ON EVERY DROP.

Drops sell out. Get early access + 10% off your first order.