Nostalgic Desserts

Nostalgic Desserts

Shop all our Nostalgic Flavors!

*Please not the "Out of Stock" flavors are there so you can sign up for a restock notification.

  • ME EAT COOKIES & MILK
    ME EAT COOKIES & MILK

    ME EAT COOKIES & MILK

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • HONEY BUNS
    HONEY BUNS

    HONEY BUNS

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • NUTTY JACK
    NUTTY JACK

    NUTTY JACK

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • NUTTY AMIGO
    NUTTY AMIGO

    NUTTY AMIGO

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • 90'S PIZZA CHIP
    90'S PIZZA CHIP

    90'S PIZZA CHIP

    $13.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • IMAGINARY PIE (Cereal Milk Cream Pie)
    IMAGINARY PIE (Cereal Milk Cream Pie)

    IMAGINARY PIE (Cereal Milk Cream Pie)

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • 90'S TOY OVEN (Mommy I Made Cookies)
    90'S TOY OVEN (Mommy I Made Cookies)

    90'S TOY OVEN (Mommy I Made Cookies)

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • FRIDAY NIGHT IN THE 90'S
    FRIDAY NIGHT IN THE 90'S

    FRIDAY NIGHT IN THE 90'S

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • CARTOON DINOSAUR BAR
    CARTOON DINOSAUR BAR

    CARTOON DINOSAUR BAR

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • WIZARD'S BREW (BUTTERBEER)
    WIZARD'S BREW (BUTTERBEER)

    WIZARD'S BREW (BUTTERBEER)

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • 90'S TOY OVEN (UNDERCOOKED BROWNIE)
    90'S TOY OVEN (UNDERCOOKED BROWNIE)

    90'S TOY OVEN (UNDERCOOKED BROWNIE)

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • MALLOW MAN FREAKSHAKE
    MALLOW MAN FREAKSHAKE

    MALLOW MAN FREAKSHAKE

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • NUTTY GRIZZLIES
    NUTTY GRIZZLIES

    NUTTY GRIZZLIES

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • NUTTYFINGER ICE CREAM BAR
    NUTTYFINGER ICE CREAM BAR

    NUTTYFINGER ICE CREAM BAR

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • PB & BANANA CREME
    PB & BANANA CREME

    PB & BANANA CREME

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • ECTO NUTTY
    ECTO NUTTY

    ECTO NUTTY

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • CRISPY TREATS CEREAL
    CRISPY TREATS CEREAL

    CRISPY TREATS CEREAL

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • LUNCH BOX GRANOLA BAR
    LUNCH BOX GRANOLA BAR

    LUNCH BOX GRANOLA BAR

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out
  • COOKIE BUTTER BAR
    COOKIE BUTTER BAR

    COOKIE BUTTER BAR

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
  • BLAST OFF BROWNIE
    BLAST OFF BROWNIE

    BLAST OFF BROWNIE

    $12.99
    Regular price
    Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
    Sold Out