FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $65 OR MORE
Jay, founder of Nutty & Nostalgic
JAY · FOUNDER Born in the 80s, raised in the 90s

I'M JAY.
I BRING BACK THE
SNACKS THEY CANCELED.

I'm a 90s kid. I grew up on snacks that don't exist anymore — the ones that disappeared off the shelf one day and just never came back. I never really got over it, so I started making them myself.

Every jar is one of those discontinued snacks, rebuilt from scratch until it tastes the way you actually remember it. Because these were never just snacks — they're the simpler, happier little moments we still carry around, and I think we could all use a bit of that back.

— Jay, Founder

THE ARCHIVE

Six things you remember. Six back in a jar. Hover or tap a case file.

COLLECT ALL FIVE A 1990s green-frosted hand pie sold with a collectible sticker THE TURTLE PIE
REVIVED 2026 COWABUNGA PIES jar COWABUNGA PIES
BOUGHT IT FOR THE SHAPE A bag of peanut-shaped peanut butter filled crisps from the 1990s THE PEANUT BUTTER CRISP
REVIVED 2026 90'S CRISPS jar 90'S CRISPS
ONLY WHEN COMPANY CAME A layered vanilla and chocolate ice cream dessert THE FANCY ICE CREAM
REVIVED 2026 90'S FANCY ICE CREAM jar 90'S FANCY ICE CREAM
CHEWED IT ALL DAY A pack of cotton candy bubble gum THE COTTON CANDY GUM
REVIVED 2026 BUBBLE NUTTY jar BUBBLE NUTTY
CULT FAVORITE A cookie butter bar COOKIE BUTTER
REVIVED 2026 COOKIE BUTTER BAR jar COOKIE BUTTER BAR
TRADED FOR IT AT LUNCH A chocolate-bottomed granola bar with candy pieces from the 1990s THE LUNCH BOX GRANOLA BAR
REVIVED 2026 LUNCH BOX GRANOLA BAR jar LUNCH BOX GRANOLA BAR

YOUR CHILDHOOD'S
BACK IN STOCK.