Regular price
Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
*NEW- Larger Size!Description:In the shimmering haze of nostalgic reverie, the Holy Grail of 90's snack lore emerges - the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Pies! With...

*NEW- Larger Size!


In the shimmering haze of nostalgic reverie, the Holy Grail of 90's snack lore emerges - the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle Pies! With the year of 1991 as the portal, this delectable treat graced our taste buds for a mere 20 weeks before fading from existence, leaving naught but a memory for us, 90's kids, to cherish. Yet, as with every legend, there are those who dare to breathe life into the tale. And so, we present to you our version of this legendary pie: Cowabunga Pies. With Layers of green glazed pie crust chips and vanilla pudding power cashew butter, this flavor will transport you back to the glory days, with every bite evoking the cry of "COWABUNGAAAAAAA DUDE!"


Please note that we are a Nut Butter Company, and not a pudding manufacturer. While we offer a vanilla pudding power cashew butter, it's essential to understand that the texture is not that of conventional pudding. Instead, it resembles whipped frosting, characterized by a creamy, fluffy, and incredibly smooth consistency. The flavor profile of our vanilla pudding power cashew butter is as close to vanilla pudding we could possibly get, boasting a milky sweet taste of vanilla.

* Layers may shift during transit!


  • Green Glazed Pie Chips- Enriched Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Vitamin B1 [Thiamin Mononitrate], Vitamin B2 [Riboflavin], Folic Acid), Palm and Palm Kernel Oil with TBHQ for Freshness, Sugar, Graham Flour, Corn Syrup, Molasses, Contains 2% or Less of Salt, Leavening (Baking Soda, Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Monocalcium Phosphate), Malt Extract, Soy Lecithin), Green Food Coloring

    Vanilla Pudding Power Nutty Fluff- Cashews, Palm Shortening (sustainably sourced), White Chips (sugar, skim milk, hydrogenated vegetable oil [palm kernel oil, soybean oil, palm oil), Vanilla Powder, Milk Powder, Vanilla Flavor, Natural & Artificial Flavors


Nutritional Label/Allergens:

  • See image in gallery above
  • Allergens: Contains Tree Nuts (Cashews), Dairy, Milk, Gluten, & Soy (manufactured in a facility that processes Peanuts)

Customer Reviews

Based on 103 reviews
Tyler Y.
Grew on me fast!

It doesn't taste quite like vanilla pudding, but the cake batter-like flavor did grow on me! This may remain my second favorite flavor!

Danielle E

The pie bits are nice, the "pudding" has a decent mouthfeel that coats the tongue. As far as resembling the actual vanilla pudding that was in the original pie, it is a hard no. The flavor does not give vanilla, it is very thick and overly sweet. The old pudding tasted like a thin custard with a vanilla forward flavor. All that being said, I am too lazy to make it myself so this is an ok substitute.


This stuff is awesome! It tastes like the TMNT pudding pies were turned into cake icing, and I love it.


definitely not the ornignal
it is ok
could be better

David Heinzman III

There pretty good although I would add more pie crust because it’s 70% Cashew butter and it’s not bad but I’d say it needs to have more gooey ness/ pudding vibes taste like Nutella dryness. The idea is there but the pudding needs to be more gooey and way more pie crust.