DON'T TAKE OUR
WORD FOR IT.

it's like a reward

SO delicious. genuinely feels like im eating cookie dough. it's a little too dry to spread on toast, but will be great mixed in to a yogurt or ice cream!

Better than I imagined

This is the most delicious snack and taste just like a fries Oreo. It's not too sweet but eliminates my sweet tooth. Definitely recommend this flavor.

Like heaven in a jar

This is EXACTLY like going to the fair and getting the deep fried cookies. This has got to be one of the best flavors yet

My favorite of the bunch

Got a few jars my first time trying this company out, and while I loved them all,this is my favorite The Oreos, a d that batter crumbly stuff is so good

Really Good

It was really good! Looking forward to when it comes back out again.

Thank you

Really great products, been in love with this company from when it started!. Thank you the nutty nostalgic taste are amazing!!

The best flavor yet

Perfect blend of flavors and consistency, with just a touch of magic .

Not Imaginary, Legit Amazing!

This just became my new favorite. I actually ordered more than one with the intention of giving one to a friend. I think I'm keeping it for myself!! It is all kinds of sweet and creamy goodness. Not to mention all the colors are fun too. The chopped cookies give it texture without being too much and it is well balanced throughout the whole jar. I also want to say that besides having absolutely yummy flavors their customer service is top notch. I always get my orders quickly and they have always answered any questions I've had. Also, luv the posts in instagram!! All the nostalgia and comments from them and others make it more fun.

CREAMY AND DREAMY!

This is one of my favorites! Thanks for "re-tooling" it and bringing it back!

Where's the Hook

One of the most 90's things I have eaten. Taste Great

Wonderful and delicious!

So far, I have purchased 4 flavors of nutty nostalgia and have been impressed with every single one. The most recent ones were given as Easter gifts and the recipient was very pleased. Matilda's Cake was chocolatey and the flavor was spot on for what I expected. I will absolutely be purchasing more in the future

FIRST ORDER WONT BE LAST

Honestly very good the cookie monster/Matildas cake rock i really wanna try YOGOS sooooo bad

Bruce would be jealous!

I've had a few other companies nut butter that made a spin off of the Matilda cake and this one smashed it out of the park! The caramel, the crispies, the chocolate cashew butter. It was very much giving death by chocolate cake in a jar! Obsessed! Would definitely order again!

I LOVE THE AMOUNT CHOCOLATE IN THIS ONE!

I don't know the Matilda reference but absolutely love the layers of rich chocolate in this jar!

Chocolate bomb!!

Really liked this one. Didn't know it was possible to make a jar of chocolate so flavorful, but somehow, it was accomplished with this jar! Highly recommended.

Unexpected wonderfulness

Had no idea what to expect with a reference to ice cream in the title, but really like the lighter yum quality of this one. Great taste and consistency. Good for a simple dessert!

Wow!

I ordered this one with the butterfinger bb's because it's my favorite candy but the shell on this ice cream one and refrigerating it really took it to the next level. I'm buying more on restock for sure!

Omg

Ommmmmg I love this one! Only regret is only ordering one jar!

Change of heart

I left a bad review because I didn't like the chocolate and it ruined it for me but this has to be the nicest customer support ever the moment they saw my review they immediately refunded me no questions asked and I appreciate that I would recommend this company if you enjoy it bc they do care about there customers

Best ever

This one is my favorite, it gave me a flashback of when i ate it as a kid. So delicious, nothing beats this one in my opinion and the hard chocolate part TOP NOTCH!!!!

Amazing product

90's Schwag is absolutely amazing and perfect for toast!

Genius Product

When I got it I anticipated it to be sweet like the other nut butters they sell. They did a good job imitating true 90s schwag. When I took the first bite I immediately started laughing. But on a positive review it's a great healthy nut butter with little to no sugar contact, tahini , chia seeds, etc makes for a great health snack on toast

Addictive!

this should be illegal, scheduled 1, definitely do not add a spoonful to a Medjol pitted Date and add dark chocolate and flaky salt ! Don't do it!

It's not sweet!!

If you're looking for dessert, this is not the one. As a person who likes to adjust my own sweet, this one is AWESOME on toast with honey or topped on a yogurt bowl with berries and/or banana. Delicious and so satisfyingly crunchy!!